Deadlock Detection and Recovery Approaches

Deadlock detection and recovery are critical parameters of operating system design and management. There are two major approaches to deadlock detection and recovery: prevention and detection with recovery.

Also Read: Deadlock Prevention in OS with Their Algorithms

Prevention enables with implementing systematic measures to prevent deadlocks from occurring, achieved via resource allocation algorithms like as the Banker’s Algorithm.

Detection and recovery involve periodically examining resource allocation to detect deadlocks and then by using recovery techniques to resolve them. Deadlock detection algorithms, including the Wait-For Graph, are used to identify deadlocks, and recovery algorithms, such as process termination, resource pre-emption, priority inversion, and rollback, are used to address the deadlock.

When to invoke a Detection Algorithm?

Deadlock detection algorithms are used to identify the presence of deadlocks in computer systems. These algorithms examine the system’s processes and resources to determine if there is a circular wait situation that could lead to a deadlock. If a deadlock is happened, then algorithm can take some essential steps to fix it and prevent it from occurring again in the next time.

The system should be made invoke the deadlock detection algorithm when it requires examining the state of the system for getting to determine if deadlock has occurred. This is typically done periodically to ensure that any potential deadlocks are identified in a timely manner.

Deadlock Detection Algorithms with Example

Deadlock detection algorithms are classified into two different categories in the respect of “Resources has Single Instance & Resources has Multiple Instance”; below shown list each one, you can check them:

Resource Allocation Graph (RAG) Algorithm

The resource allocation graph is a graphic representation of the state of the system that helps to depict the relationships in between processes and resources. It contains information about all the activities that are holding or waiting for resources, as well as the instances of resources, whether available or in use by processes. In a resource allocation graph:

Processes are represented by circular nodes or vertices, while resources are represented using rectangles.

Edges in the graph represent the relationships between processes and resources. There are two types of edges: request edges and assignment edges.

Example:

Consider the following example to illustrate the resource allocation graph:

Suppose we have 3 processes, P1, P2, and P3, and two resource types, R1 and R2. Each resource has a single instance. According to the graph:

P1 is using R1.

P2 is holding R2 while waiting for R1.

P3 is waiting for both R1 and R2.

The graph is deadlock-free since no cycle is formed in the graph.

The resource allocation graph visually represents the state of a system, showing the relationships between processes and resources, and can be used to analyse resource allocation and detect potential deadlocks.

Advantages Are:

• It provides the clear and intuitive graphical representation of the relationships between processes and resources in a system.

• Easy to understand and visualize, making it a useful tool for system administrators and developers.

• Effectively detects cycles in the graph, which can be indicative of potential deadlocks.

Disadvantages Are:

• It becomes a complex and hard to manage with a large number of processes and resources, leading to increased computational overhead.

• May indicate potential deadlocks that do not actually result in a deadlock situation, leading to unnecessary actions being taken.

• RAG primarily focuses on detection, and it does not inherently prevent deadlocks. Prevention strategies are often required in addition to detection.

The Wait-For Graph Algorithm

The Wait-For Graph algorithm is a deadlock detection technique used in computer systems to detect and resolve deadlocks. It works by constructing a directed graph, where nodes represent processes, and edges represent the resources held by the processes. If a cycle is detected in the graph, it indicates a deadlock.

Example:

Consider a system with three processes (P1, P2, P3) and three resources (R1, R2, R3). Each resource has two instances. The following is the initial state:

Process P1 is holding one instance of R1.

Process P2 is holding one instance of R2.

Process P3 is holding one instance of R3.

Initial Wait-For Graph:

P1 —–> R2(1)

|

P2 —–> R3(1)

|

P3 —–> R1(1)

In the graph:

Arrows indicate the waiting relationship (a process is waiting for a resource).

The direction of the arrow points from the process to the resource it is waiting for.

Resource Request:

Let’s say that Process P1 requests another instance of R2:

Updated Wait-For Graph:

P1 —–> R2(2)

|

P2 —–> R3(1)

|

P3 —–> R1(1)

Resource Release:

Now, let’s say that Process P2 releases its hold on R3:

Updated Wait-For Graph:

P1 —–> R2(2)

|

P2

|

P3 —–> R1(1)

Banker’s Algorithm

The Banker’s Algorithm is a resource allocation and deadlock detection algorithm used in operating systems. It is named after its ability to simulate the allocation of resources in a way that ensures the system remains in a safe state, preventing deadlock. When a new process enters the system, it must declare the maximum number of instances of each resource type it may ever claim.

Also Read: Deadlock Avoidance Algorithm with Examples

The algorithm then checks for safety by simulating the allocation of the maximum possible amounts of all resources and makes an “s-state” check to test for possible deadlock conditions before deciding whether allocation should be allowed to continue.

Example:

Consider a system with five processes (P1, P2, P3, P4, P5) and three types of resources (A, B, C). The maximum demand, current allocation, and available resources are given as follows:

Maximum Demand Matrix:

          A   B   C

P1      7   5   3

P2      3   2   2

P3      9   0   2

P4      2   2   2

P5      4   3   3

Current Allocation Matrix:

          A   B   C

P1      0   1   0

P2      2   0   0

P3      3   0   2

P4      2   1   1

P5      0   0   2

Available Resources:

                   A   B   C

Available: 3   3   2

Example Calculation:

Let’s consider Process P4 requests (1, 0, 2).

Updated Allocation Matrix:

           A   B   C

P1      0   1   0

P2      2   0   0

P3      3   0   2

P4      3   1   3   (Updated)

P5      0   0   2

Updated Need Matrix:

           A   B   C

P1      7   4   3

P2      1   2   2

P3      6   0   0

P4      1   1   1

P5      4   3   1

Updated Available Resources:

                   A   B   C

Available: 2   2   0   (Updated)

Now, the system checks if it is in a safe state. If yes, the request is granted; otherwise, the process must wait.

The Banker’s Algorithm repeats these steps for subsequent resource requests.

This example demonstrates the basic steps of the Banker’s Algorithm, and it showcases how the system ensures that resource requests do not lead to an unsafe state, ultimately preventing deadlocks.

Advantages Are:

• Effectively prevents deadlocks by checking whether resource allocations will lead to an unsafe state.

• It provides a safety check to ensure that resource requests can be granted without causing deadlock.

• It can handle dynamic resource requests and releases during the execution of processes.

Disadvantages Are:

• Assumes a centralized control system, which might not be practical in distributed or decentralized environments.

• It can be computationally complex, especially for large systems, as it involves matrix operations.

• In situations where resource needs are highly dynamic, the conservative nature of the algorithm may lead to underutilization of resources.

Dijkstra’s Deadlock Detection Algorithm

Dijkstra’s Deadlock Detection Algorithm is a method used to detect deadlocks in a system. It works by constructing a wait-for graph, which is a directed graph that represents the relationships between processes and resources. If the wait-for graph contains a cycle, then a deadlock has occurred. The algorithm can then take appropriate action to resolve the deadlock.

Example:

Consider a system with three processes (P1, P2, P3) and three resources (R1, R2, R3). Each resource has two instances. The following is the initial state:

Initial Resource Allocation Graph:

         R1(1)

          |

P1 —–> P2

          |

         R2(1)

         R3(1)

          |

         P3

In the graph:

Arrows indicate the request relationship (a process is requesting a resource).

The direction of the arrow points from the process to the resource it is requesting.

Example Execution:

Initialize:

Worklist: {P1, P2, P3}

Marked: {}

Check for Cycles:

Select P1 from Worklist. P1 is not in Marked, so mark it and add its neighbors (P2) to Worklist.

Worklist: {P2, P3}

Marked: {P1}

Select P2 from Worklist. P2 is not in Marked, so mark it and add its neighbors (P1, R2) to Worklist.

Worklist: {P3, P1, R2}

Marked: {P1, P2}

Select P3 from Worklist. P3 is not in Marked, so mark it and add its neighbors (R3) to Worklist.

Worklist: {P1, R2, R3}

Marked: {P1, P2, P3}

Select P1 from Worklist. P1 is already in Marked, indicating a cycle.

Other Deadlock Detection Algorithms in OS:

Timeout Mechanisms

Timeout mechanisms are used to limit the amount of time a process can wait for a resource, preventing indefinite waiting and breaking potential deadlocks.

In the context of database management systems (DBMS), timeout mechanisms force a transaction to release its locks after a certain period of time, thereby preventing deadlocks.

Lock and transaction timeouts may be used in place of, or in addition to, regular deadlock detection. If lock or transaction timeouts are set, database operations will return a specific error code when the timeout has expired, allowing applications to distinguish between true deadlock and timeout situations.

The accuracy of the timeout depends on how often deadlock detection is performed. If there are no new blocked lock requests, a pending timeout will never trigger, so a separate deadlock detection thread or process is recommended if the application depends on timeouts.

State-based Mechanisms

State-based mechanisms analyse the current state of the system to detect deadlocks and take appropriate actions to resolve them.

These mechanisms can be applied in various contexts, such as distributed systems and operating systems.

Tools Used for Automated Detection

Automated deadlock detection tools are software programs that can be used to identify and resolve deadlocks in a computer system. These tools can be used in various contexts, such as database management systems, distributed systems, and operating systems. Here are some examples of tools used for automated deadlock detection:

SQL Sentry:

SQL Sentry is a SQL Server deadlock monitoring tool that enables users to quickly recognize when a deadlock has occurred, understand its root causes, and see actions they can take to reduce the chances of a repeat deadlock.

DELFIN+:

DELFIN+ is a deadlock detection tool for CCS processes that uses heuristic-based search strategies to identify deadlocks and take appropriate actions to resolve them.

Advantages of Deadlock Detection in OS

Advantages of deadlock detection in operating systems include:

Also Read: What is Deadlock in OS with their Examples? Easy Guide

Improved System Stability: Detecting and resolving deadlocks can help to improve the stability of the system, preventing system freezes and ensuring that processes can continue to execute.

Better Resource Utilization: By detecting and resolving deadlocks, the operating system can ensure that resources are efficiently utilized and that the system remains responsive to user requests.

Prevents Hangs: Deadlock detection helps to prevent system freezes by identifying and resolving deadlocks that is ensuring the system remains responsive to user requests.

Optimizes Allocation: Deadlock detection algorithms can help identify and optimize resource allocation, ensuring that resources are distributed effectively and efficiently.

Easy Implementation: Some deadlock detection algorithms, such as the Wait-For Graph, are relatively simple to implement and can be used in a wide range of operating systems and systems with different resource allocation and synchronization requirements.

Disadvantages of Deadlock Detection in OS

The disadvantages of deadlock detection in operating systems include:

Detection Overhead: Deadlock detection algorithms can introduce a significant overhead in terms of performance, as the system must regularly check for deadlocks and take appropriate action to resolve them.

Delayed Resolution: Deadlock detection algorithms may respond after a deadlock occurs, rather than preventing it, which can lead to system freezes or crashes.

Resource Usage: Deadlock detection algorithms can consume additional system resources for monitoring, potentially affecting overall system performance.

Complexity: Deadlock detection algorithms can be complex to implement, especially if they use advanced techniques such as the Resource Allocation Graph or Time-stamping.

Potential False Positives: Some deadlock detection algorithms may detect non-deadlock situations as deadlocks, leading to unnecessary resource release or process termination.

FAQs (Frequently Asked Questions)

Can deadlock detection prevent deadlocks?

Deadlock detection itself does not prevent deadlocks but identifies their presence. Prevention strategies, such as careful resource allocation and transaction management, are used alongside detection to minimize the occurrence of deadlocks.

What are various techniques used for deadlock detection?

In this article, we have been already shown many deadlock detection methods in operating system; you can navigate them.

How does deadlock detection impact system performance?

Deadlock detection can introduce computational overhead and impacting system performance. The frequency of deadlock gets to check and the efficiency of detection algorithms influence the extent of this impact.

Final Remarks

Make ensure that you have been fully understood about what is deadlock detection in OS with their algorithms and example with ease. If this article is helpful for you, then please share it along with your friends, family members or relatives over social media platforms like as Facebook, Instagram, Linked In, Twitter, and more.

Also Read: What is Thread in OS? Types of Threads in OS!

If you have any experience, tips, tricks, or query regarding this issue? You can drop a comment!

Happy Learning!!